Simms Freestone VS Tributary Waders: Which is best in 2023

Are you in the market for new waders? Whether you’re a weekend angler or an experienced pro, it pays to do your research before investing in this important piece of gear. While there’s no shortage of options out there, two standouts are the Simms Freestone vs Tributary Waders. In this blog post, we’ll compare these two models head-to-head to determine which one comes out on top when it comes to fit, comfort, performance and overall value for money spent. So if you’re searching for reliable waterproof protection that won’t break the bank, read on to find out which pair is better suited to your needs!

Key Feature Difference of Simms Freestone vs Tributary Waders:

When it comes to waders, two of the biggest names in the outdoor industry are Simms Freestone and Tributary. Both offer excellent quality and value for money – but how do they compare? Here we take a look at the key feature differences between Simms Freestone and Tributary Waders.

Material:

The Simms Freestone Waders are constructed with a 4-layer Toray QuadraLam fabric, while the Tributary waders feature a 3-layer waterproof material. The 4-layer Toray QuadraLam fabric is highly breathable but also has more abrasion resistance than the 3-layer material used in the Tributary waders.

It is also much more durable, making it the better choice for longer fishing trips or tougher terrain. In terms of comfort and fit, the Simms Freestone waders are designed to provide a snug but comfortable fit with articulated legs that allow for maximum range of motion.

Design:

The Simms Freestone Waders are constructed with an ergonomic design that fits closely to the legs for increased comfort and mobility while fishing. The Tributary waders have a looser fit, which provides more room when it comes time to layer up in colder conditions.

The Simms waders feature a cargo pocket and self-fabric gravel guard, while the Tributary design does not. The Tributary waders are more economical for those on a budget but offer less features than the Freestone model. 

Comfort:

Simms Freestone Waders provide superior comfort in the stream due to their articulated legs and adjustable suspenders with Opposing buckles. They have a three-layer, breathable fabric which allows for improved airflow, allowing you to stay comfortable even after hours of fishing.

The Tributary waders lack these features and are generally less comfortable, especially when fishing long days. The superior comfort and adjustable features of the Simms Freestone waders make it an ideal choice for any angler looking to stay comfortable while fishing all-day.

Durability:

Simms Freestone Waders are made with high-quality materials which make them more durable and resilient against abrasion, punctures and other damage typical of wading in rocky streams. The Tributary waders, on the other hand, are not as well-constructed and are more prone to developing rips and tears over time.

While they may be cheaper in the short term, Tributary waders are not as likely to last as long as Simms Freestone Waders. Therefore, if you are looking for a pair of waders with increased durability, Simms Freestone Waders should be your go-to. 

Affordability:

Simms Freestone Waders come with a higher price tag than Tributary waders, due to their superior comfort and durability. However, the long-term cost savings from investing in quality gear may be well worth the initial investment for serious fishers. Tributary waders offer a more economical option for those looking to save money on their fishing gear. With the variety of styles and sizes available, Tributary Waders are sure to fit any angler’s budget. 

Storage Features:

Simms Freestone Waders offer several convenient storage features, including two waterproof and easy-access chest pockets, plus an integrated utility tab on the back for attaching a net or other accessories. The Tributary Waders, on the other hand, offer a single chest pocket and no utility tab. This means you can store fewer items in or on the wader and may need to use an external net holder for attaching your net.

Suspenders/Belt Loop System:

The Simms Freestone Waders feature an adjustable belt loop system with opposing buckles that allow you to quickly and easily adjust the fit of the waders. The Tributary Waders, in contrast, come with an integrated Y-back suspender design that offers a more secure fit but does not give you as much flexibility when adjusting for size. Both Suspenders/Belt Loop Systems offer adjustable straps for a comfortable fit. However, the Simms Freestone Waders provide more options when it comes to adjusting your waders to the perfect size

Warranty:

Simms Freestone Waders come with a full warranty that covers any manufacturing defects and wear and tear in the fabric or hardware. The Tributary Waders, on the other hand, have a limited one-year warranty which only covers manufacturer defects and not wear and tear.

In the case of a manufacturing defect, Simms will repair or replace the waders without question; in the case of Tributary Waders, they may or may not be replaced depending on their discretion. This makes Simms Freestone Waders a much better choice for anglers who use their gear frequently and need assurance that it will last.

Simms Freestone Waders Reviews:

Simms Freestone Waders are the perfect choice for anglers looking for a high-quality, durable wader option. The Freestone wader is constructed with four-layer GORE-TEX® Pro Shell fabric and features articulated leg design for ease of movement. It also has an adjustable webbing suspender system with low-profile buckles, an adjustable waistband with a quick-release belt buckle and a flip out pocket for storage.

The Freestone wader provides excellent waterproofing and breathability that keeps you dry even in the coldest of temperatures. The fabric is designed to withstand rugged conditions without sacrificing comfort or durability.

Simms Freestone Waders

Pros
  • Constructed with four-layer GORE-TEX® Pro Shell fabric for ultimate durability Articulated leg design for ease of movement
  • Adjustable webbing suspender system with low-profile buckles
  • Adjustable waistband with a quick release belt buckle
  • Flip out pocket for storage
  • Excellent waterproofing and breathability
Cons
  • Expensive compared to other brands
  • Heavy weight due to four-layer fabric construction
  • Not as many pockets or add-ons as some of the other waders on the market.

Simms Tributary Waders Review:

When it comes to waders, Simms is one of the leading brands on the market. The company’s tributary wader series are a testament to their quality and excellent craftsmanship. For those who want waterproof breathable protection without breaking the bank, these are a great option. The Tributary Waders come in a variety of styles, including chest waders and stocking foot waders.

They feature a three-layer nylon upper and four-layer waterproof breathable lower with adjustable neoprene suspenders for custom fit. The seams are stitched, taped and sealed to ensure complete waterproof protection.

Tributary Waders

Pros
  • Durable three-layer nylon fabric upper
  • Four-layer waterproof breathable lower for ultimate protection
  • Adjustable neoprene suspenders for custom fit
  • Stitched, taped and sealed seams for complete waterproof protection
  • Affordable compared to other brands.
Cons
  • Not as durable as some of the other waders on the market
  • Lack of features compared to higher-end waders, such as pockets and add-ons
  • Not suitable for extremely cold temperatures.

Conclusion:

If you are looking for reliable and comfortable wading gear, Simms Freestone Waders are the way to go. With their superior comfort, durability and long-term cost savings, they are the ideal gear for any serious fisherman. However, if your budget does not allow for such a purchase, then Tributary waders may be a more suitable option for you. Either way, make sure to invest in the best gear you can afford to ensure a safe and enjoyable wading experience.

Related posted: Simms vs Redington waders

Related FAQs:

What are Simms Tributary waders?

Tributary waders, such as the ones designed by Simms Freestone, are designed to provide anglers with a lightweight and breathable option for wading in warmer conditions. Tributary waders are typically made from a lighter weight material than traditional neoprene waders and provide a comfortable and cool way to fish. The breathable material of tributary waders allows air to circulate around your body, preventing you from getting too hot or sweaty while in the water.

Is Simms Tributary waders Better than Freestone?

Simms tributary waders vs. Freestone waders has been a debate among fishermen for many years. Both popular models of waders have their own advantages and disadvantages, and it really depends on the needs of each individual fisherman as to which type is better for them. While both types are made with durable materials that provide reliable protection from the elements, there are distinct differences between the two.

How many years do waders last?

The longevity of a pair of waders is largely determined by the material they are made from. Simms Freestone waders feature four-layer GORE-TEX® fabric, which provides superior durability and breathability. This type of construction ensures that these waders will last for many seasons. On the other hand, Tributary waders feature a three-layer fabric that is lightweight and durable, but may not last as long.

Generally speaking, Tributary waders have a lifespan of 3 to 5 years with regular use, while Simms Freestone waders can last up to 7 years or longer when properly cared for.

Which waders are most durable?

If you’re in the market for new waders to take on your next fishing trip, it’s important to consider the durability of each type. Simms Freestone Waders offer superior protection and are built tough with four-layer GORE-TEX Pro Shell fabric.

This makes them more abrasion resistant and able to withstand harsh conditions out on the water. On top of this, Freestone waders feature DWR (durable water repellent) finish and a reinforced, taped internal seam construction that ensures maximum performance all season long.